[email protected]

Not going to lie, I got banned so I made my own World News Community. This community differs because there’s no silly bot, I’ll happily listen to the communities voice, and we’re a bit more lax on rules policing.

Feel free to come on by and comment. I would love to foster a News community that’s active in discussion.

  • tal@lemmy.todayEnglish
    0·
    2 months ago

    An instance needs to have a subscribed user to get the posts and comments, which have shown up. The votes, however, are absent.

    • PhilipTheBucket@ponder.catEnglish
      0·
      2 months ago

      That’s not quite true. If a community was resolved but no one’s currently subscribed to it, for example because someone searched for it or subscribed and then unsubscribed, you’ll see exactly the situation that you’re looking at. You’ll see partial content and almost no votes.

      • tal@lemmy.todayEnglish
        0·
        2 months ago

        considers

        Fedia.io appears to have a pretty complete history of comments and posts. Lemmyverse.net reports 78 posts, and that’s about how many posts picks up. It doesn’t see the votes, however.

        Granted, I haven’t tested the order in which votes are fetched. Maybe comments and posts get priority over votes, and if a user unsubscribes, that terminates fetching votes.

        looks further

        On lemmyverse.net, the community statistics read:

        90 subscribed users. 1.9k active users.

        That ratio is pretty dramatically out-of-whack with all other communities on lemmyverse. That’s sufficient to place it in the top 100 communities on the Threadiverse by active users, which I believe includes vote activity.

        But it has only 90 subscribers, which is way down the list.

        The subscriber count I can believe, for a new community. But for the active user count to be that high, there’d need to be a very high proportion of user account activity, with few subscriptions.

        EDIT: Additionally, if one sorts by active weekly users, every other community shown on the same visible page in the lemmyverse community list – the communities with a roughly comparable active user rate – has between an order of magnitude and two orders of magnitude more comments. So basically, very few of these users could be commenting, but a high proportion would need to be voting.

        EDIT2: Okay, moist.catsweat.com is another mbin instance that has indexed the community. Unlike fedia.io, that instance does have votes for the past few posts, and while there are a lot of upvotes relative to comments, one can see the users users doing so, and they appear to be real users, not bots. It’s a lot of upvotes for a new community, but that could be just unusual, and I’d believe that the propagation of votes is due to lemmy quirks.

        Sorry, @[email protected]. Just didn’t want to have spammers abusing the system. This is probably legit; I’ll withdraw my concerns.